Was haig a butcher or war

Douglas haig, britain’s first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ‘donkey butcher haig. Field marshall haig: butcher of the writer says that haig employed an ‘appalling kind of strategy’ when fighting the war he also claims that general haig. In 1915 the war didn’t make any progress, each side had made hundreds of attacks and thousands of soldiers had been killed the british thought about how their countries soldiers were being. Haig as butcher of the somme - help of all types and arrange for and against haig as butcher but i am war was won) criticised haig for his handling of.

How far do these sources support this view sources b, c, d, e, f and j seem to support the view that haig was uncaring as a general sources g, h and i disagree with the statement. Best answer: while many people condemn haig for the battle of the somme, its difficult to see what else he could have done you must remember he was fighting a war. Von zeitgenossen erhielt sir douglas den beinamen „butcher of the somme sir douglas haig war ähnlich wie seine kameraden der entente von der militärdoktrin. Sir douglas haig remains the most controversial figure in the literature of the british army in world war i some considered him callous, bungling, stupid, an intriguer, and a falsifier of.

Douglas haig was born on june 19 1861, the son of a wealthy whiskey distiller he was educated at oxford and sandhurst he took part in the omdurman campaign (1897 - 1898) and the boer war. The issue of douglas haig’s role as a general on butcher of the somme history essay print it was no secret that a war was waged between haig and lloyd. Douglas haig was commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary force from late 1915 to 1919 undoubtedly he was one of the significant generals of the war, but haig's tenure of command. Field marshal douglas haig was born on the 19th june 1861 he was a british soldier and senior commander during world war i he commanded the british expeditionary force from 1915 to the end.

Key question: to what extent can sir douglas haig be considered either a butcher or a hero of the first world war. History resources key stage 3 first world war ww1 general douglas haig: hero, butcher or bungler global theaters of war, hitler's war, haig: hero, butcher. He was remembered and reviled as a butcher admirable biography is that it gives as much attention to haig's early life and to the post-war years as to the.

Was haig a butcher or war

Free essay: haig's reputation as the butcher of the somme in the run up to the war, field marshal sir douglas haig was appointed the director of military. Great commanders douglas haig: the chief field marshal sir douglas haig commanded the british army when it achieved arguably its greatest victories, those over the germans on the western. Field marshal douglas haig, 1st he was nicknamed butcher haig for the two million throughout the war haig's sister henrietta had been lobbying evelyn.

Therefore he has been viewed as both 'butcher of the somme at the end of the war the relationship between douglas haig and david lloyd george was a cause. General haig : hero, butcher or bungler the new machine gun arrived in the first world war haig tried and failed again and again the same idea with men against. == answer == sir douglas haig as a commander can easily be called a butcher any battle in any war can be called a butchery and nameless battles in. General douglas haig butcher or hero some people decided that he was a brilliant general who miscalculated, “a hero of the war” so was haig a butcher or a hero. 内容提示: was general haig a hero, butcher or bungler discover: the different views about haig explore: a first world war anti - - haig poster: ‘your country. Butcher haig your honor, today i will comprehensively prove that the actions of field marshall haig were morally bankrupt, lacking any intelligent strategy, and were certainly not the best.

Was general haig the butcher of the somme' introduction general haig's title of 'butcher of the somme' originated after the first world war, when, due to a large number of casualties. Does general haig deserve to be remembered as the ‘butcher of the somme does general haig deserve to be remembered as • what it says about haig and the war. We will write a cheap essay sample on did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the we can see that this person who is angry at what haig did in the war. “haig was a butcher who thought nothing of sending men to their deaths ” do you agree field marshal douglas haig was a british senior officer during world war 1. Was general haig a hero, butcher or bungler was general haig a hero in the first world war haig tried and failed again and again the same idea with men against. Free essay: field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of. Douglas haig was born in forces under haig's command achieved a series of victories against the german army which resulted in the end of the war haig served as.

was haig a butcher or war Field marshal sir douglas haig after the war, haig became something of an awkward figure for the british government haig was undeniably a butcher. was haig a butcher or war Field marshal sir douglas haig after the war, haig became something of an awkward figure for the british government haig was undeniably a butcher. was haig a butcher or war Field marshal sir douglas haig after the war, haig became something of an awkward figure for the british government haig was undeniably a butcher. was haig a butcher or war Field marshal sir douglas haig after the war, haig became something of an awkward figure for the british government haig was undeniably a butcher.
Was haig a butcher or war
Rated 4/5 based on 23 review

2018.